Rules for noticing and understanding the movements of the soul (First Week)
Discernment of Spirits
The First Week rules for the discernment of spirits are probably the most used pages of the whole book of the Exercises, retreats or no retreats. In fourteen short rules St Ignatius teaches us to notice what is going on inside, to recognise where each inner movement comes from and to know what to do with it: welcome what comes from God and reject what does not.
The text of St Ignatius
These rules help us notice and understand the different movements stirred up in the soul: the good, to receive them, and the bad, to reject them.
1.How the enemy works in those living in sin
In people who go from mortal sin to mortal sin, the enemy usually offers apparent pleasures, filling the imagination with sensual delights to keep them in their vices. The good spirit works the opposite way, pricking and stinging their conscience.
2.How he works in those who are growing
In those who are cleansing themselves of their sins and rising from good to better, it is typical of the evil spirit to gnaw at them, sadden them and put obstacles in their way with false reasons, so that they do not go forward. It is typical of the good spirit to give courage and strength, consolation and peace.
3.What spiritual consolation is
When some inner movement is stirred in the soul by which it is set on fire with love of its Creator and Lord. Also when it sheds tears out of sorrow for its sins or for the Passion. Finally, every increase of hope, faith and charity, and every inner joy that calls and draws us to heavenly things.
4.What spiritual desolation is
The very opposite of consolation: darkness of soul, turmoil, attraction to low and earthly things, restlessness, temptation, lack of faith, hope and love; the soul finds itself lazy, lukewarm, sad and as if cut off from its Creator.
5.The golden rule: in desolation, make no change
In time of desolation never make a change, but stay firm and constant in the resolutions and decisions you held before the desolation. For just as the good spirit guides us in consolation, the evil spirit guides us in desolation, and his counsel can never lead us right.
6.What to do in desolation
Although we should not change our earlier resolutions, it helps a great deal to push firmly against the desolation itself: praying and meditating more, examining ourselves more, and taking on some suitable penance.
7.How to behave in consolation
Whoever is in consolation should think how they will act in the desolation that will follow, and gather new strength for that time.
What they are and where they sit in the Exercises
They are found at nos. 313-327, near the end of the book, alongside other rules and notes. Their title says it all: rules “for perceiving and understanding to some extent the various movements produced in the soul, the good, that they may be accepted, and the bad, that they may be rejected” (no. 313). Ignatius adds that they are “more suited to the First Week”, that is, to someone who is beginning to turn back to God and put their life in order.
There is a second, subtler set for the Second Week (nos. 328-336), meant for people already seeking God generously, whom the enemy tempts “under the appearance of good” (no. 10). Whoever gives the Exercises should not explain every rule to everyone, but according to what each person is going through (nos. 8-9). These first fourteen are the foundation.
The rules grew out of Ignatius’ own experience. Convalescing at Loyola in 1521, he noticed that some thoughts left him joyful while others, which pleased him at first, left him dry and discontented. That, he says in his Autobiography, was where he began to recognise the different spirits that were moving him.
Three verbs: notice, understand, act
The first task is to notice. Many people live without paying attention to what they feel, or feel things without asking where they lead. Ignatius asks us to attend to the movements of the soul: joys, sadnesses, desires, fears, the urge to pray or to give everything up.
The second is to understand. The first two rules teach that the same feeling can mean different things depending on the direction of a life. In someone going from sin to sin, the evil spirit proposes apparent pleasures and the good spirit stings the conscience (no. 314). In someone rising from good to better, it is the other way round: the evil spirit bites, saddens and puts obstacles in the way with false reasons, while the good spirit gives courage, strength, consolations and inspirations (no. 315). It is not enough to ask whether something feels good; we have to ask where it is pushing us.
The third is to act: accept what comes from God and reject what does not. The Catechism teaches that the Holy Spirit makes us discern between trials, which are needed for growth, and temptation, which leads to sin (no. 2847).
Consolation and desolation
Ignatius defines spiritual consolation broadly: when the soul is set on fire with love of its Creator, when it sheds tears that move it to love of God, and in general every increase of faith, hope and charity, and every inner joy that calls and draws to heavenly things, leaving the soul quiet and at peace in its Lord (no. 316). It is not the same as feeling good: there can be consolation in tears.
Desolation is the opposite: darkness, turmoil, a pull towards low things, restlessness, temptations, a lack of faith, hope and love, the soul slothful, lukewarm, sad and as if cut off from its Creator (no. 317). It should not be confused with depression or exhaustion: desolation is a spiritual state, and if sadness lasts a long time or weighs too heavily, it is right to see a doctor as well.
Ignatius gives three possible causes of desolation: our own lukewarmness or negligence in spiritual things; a trial from God, to see how far we will serve him without the reward of consolations; and a lesson in humility, so that we know devotion is a gift and not something we produce ourselves (no. 322).
What to do in each season
The best-known rule is the fifth: “in time of desolation never make a change”, but stay firm in the resolutions held before, because just as the good spirit guides us in consolation, in desolation it is the evil spirit who counsels us (no. 318). Big decisions are not made in the dark night.
Not changing resolutions does not mean standing still. Ignatius advises moving strongly against the desolation: more prayer, more examination and some suitable penance (no. 319). He asks us to remember that grace is still there even when it is not felt (no. 320), to work at being patient and to trust that consolation will soon return (no. 321).
In consolation, by contrast, the advice is to prepare for the desolation to come by gathering new strength, and to stay humble, remembering how little we can do without that grace (nos. 323-324).
The enemy’s tactics
The last three rules describe how the evil spirit works. It grows bolder before someone who is afraid of it and weakens before someone who stands up to it firmly (no. 325). It wants secrecy, like a seducer who does not want the young woman to tell her father anything: so it is disarmed when everything is talked through with a confessor or another spiritual person who knows its tricks (no. 326). And it attacks at the weakest point, like a commander studying the walls before an assault (no. 327).
Hence a very Ignatian habit: talking about one’s inner life with someone trustworthy. The Catechism recalls that the Spirit gives some of the faithful gifts of wisdom, faith and discernment to help others in prayer (no. 2690). Pope Francis devoted a cycle of catecheses on discernment to these themes in 2022 and 2023.
Pray it with the Bible
- 1 John 4:1: “Beloved, do not trust every spirit but test the spirits to see whether they belong to God.”
- Galatians 5:22-23: The fruit of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, generosity, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control. These are the signs of consolation.
- 2 Corinthians 11:14: Even Satan masquerades as an angel of light: deception can come looking like something good.
- 1 Peter 5:8-9: The enemy prowls around looking for someone to devour; resist him, steadfast in faith.
- Matthew 4:1-11: In the desert Jesus does not argue with the tempter or change course: he answers with the Word and stands firm.
How to pray it, step by step
1.Do the examen every night
Spend ten minutes going over the day with God. Give thanks and ask yourself what moved you, what gave you joy and what took away your peace.
2.Name what you feel
“I had a bad day” is not enough. Look for the exact word: restlessness, discouragement, a desire to pray, peace, enthusiasm, dryness.
3.Look at where it leads
Ask whether that movement draws you closer to God and to others, or shuts you in on yourself. The direction matters more than the feeling.
4.Recognise your season
Are you in consolation or desolation? Write it down. Over time you will see patterns: when they come and what sets them off.
5.In desolation, don’t change
If you are in desolation, don’t make important decisions or drop what you decided in peace. Pray a little more, not less.
6.In consolation, get ready
If you are in consolation, give thanks and think about what you will do when dryness comes. Write down a sentence to remember then.
7.Tell someone
Talk regularly with a confessor or spiritual director. What is brought into the light loses its power to deceive you.
Questions for your prayer
- Which moment this week left me at peace, and which left me unsettled?
- Is there a decision I am about to take in a time of desolation?
- What seemingly good reasons are keeping me from prayer today?
- What is my weak point, the place where temptation usually gets in?
- Is there something I keep secret that it would do me good to talk about with someone?
Frequently asked questions
How many rules for discernment are there in the Exercises?
Fourteen for the First Week (nos. 313-327) and eight for the Second Week (nos. 328-336). This page summarises seven of the first set.
Is desolation the same as depression?
No. Desolation is a spiritual state St Ignatius describes to guide prayer. Depression is an illness that needs medical care. The two can overlap, and then both kinds of help are needed.
Why shouldn’t we make changes in desolation?
Because, according to Ignatius, it is the evil spirit who counsels us in desolation, and what we decide then usually comes from discouragement rather than light (no. 318). The wise thing is to wait until we are at peace.
Can these rules be used outside a retreat?
Yes. Many people use them in the daily examen. It helps a great deal to talk them over with a spiritual director, as Ignatius himself recommends (no. 326).
Updated 3 November 2026
Adapted from the Spiritual Exercises of St Ignatius of Loyola (1548).