Skip to content
All articles

Learn

From the nihil obstat to the devil’s advocate: how the Church declares a saint

The Church does not “make” saints: after a study that can take decades, she declares that a person lived the Gospel heroically and is already with God. The path is almost always the same: Servant of God, Venerable, Blessed and Saint. But along the way there are steps and words hardly anyone knows, and in the game they were the answers worth the most.

7 min read

Christ glorified in heaven, surrounded by angels and a great crowd of saints, painting by Fra Angelico
Image: Fra Angelico, “Christ Glorified in the Court of Heaven”, predella of the Fiesole altarpiece (c. 1423–1424), National Gallery, London, public domain

First, the basics

To canonize means to enter someone in the “canon”, the list of saints the Church holds up to everyone as models and intercessors (Catechism, 828). In the first millennium, saints were recognised by popular acclaim and the approval of the local bishop. Between the twelfth and thirteenth centuries the pope reserved canonization to himself, and today the process follows the rules St John Paul II set out in 1983 in the constitution Divinus perfectionis Magister.

This was the third prompt of Mustard Seed #1. Here are the terms of the process, from the one fewest players knew to the best known. The four steps are summed up at the end.

1. The offering of life

It was the rarest answer of the day, and it is the newest path. Until 2017 there were two roads to the altars: martyrdom and heroic virtue. That year, in the apostolic letter Maiorem hac dilectionem, Pope Francis opened a third: that of someone who freely offers their life for others and accepts a certain and early death out of love.

The name comes from the words of Jesus: “No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for one’s friends” (John 15:13). Think of someone who stays to care for the contagious sick knowing it will cost them their life. Unlike a martyr, they are not killed out of hatred for the faith; and unlike heroic virtue, it is not a whole life under examination, but that act of love and a consistent Christian life up to that point. Beatification still requires a miracle.

2. The nihil obstat

In Latin it means “nothing stands in the way”. Before opening a cause, the bishop of the diocese where the person died asks the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, in Rome, whether there is any obstacle. A yes is the nihil obstat.

You may know the phrase from somewhere else: it is printed in the first pages of many Catholic books, alongside the imprimatur, to show that a censor has read them and found nothing contrary to the faith.

3. The canonical recognition of the remains

At some point in the cause, a commission exhumes the person’s remains, in the presence of witnesses and a forensic doctor. They confirm the remains are really theirs, record their condition and take relics. Then they are reburied, often somewhere easier for the faithful to visit.

No one is looking for an incorrupt body: that is neither a requirement nor a proof of holiness. If it happens it is recorded, but the Church does not treat it as a miracle in itself.

4. The medical board

Beatification and canonization each require a miracle attributed to the person’s intercession, and almost always it is a healing. A group of doctors, the Dicastery’s medical board, examines the case: the diagnosis, the treatment, the tests. They must conclude that the healing was rapid, complete, lasting and unexplainable by current science.

The doctors do not say there was a miracle; they say they can find no explanation. Whether the healing came through the candidate’s intercession is judged afterwards by the theologians and the cardinals.

5. The theological consultors and the relator

Once everything gathered in the diocese reaches Rome, a relator is appointed, an expert of the Dicastery who guides the preparation of the positio (see below). When it is ready, about nine theological consultors study it and vote on whether the person lived the virtues to a heroic degree or died a martyr.

If most vote in favour, the case goes to the cardinals and bishops who are members of the Dicastery, and finally to the pope, who makes the decision.

6. Equipollent canonization

This is the exception to everything above. The pope can declare someone a saint without the usual process or a new miracle, when there is an ancient, continuous and widespread cult and a well-documented reputation for holiness. Benedict XVI did it for Hildegard of Bingen in 2012, and Francis for the Jesuit Peter Faber in 2013 and for José de Anchieta, the apostle of Brazil, in 2014.

7. The diocesan inquiry

It all begins in the diocese where the person died, generally at least five years after their death. The pope can waive that wait, as Benedict XVI did for John Paul II, whose cause opened a few weeks after he died. To begin, there must be a reputation for holiness: people must consider the person holy and ask for their help.

In this phase a tribunal hears witnesses who knew them and gathers all their writings, which theological censors examine. From the opening of the cause, the person is called a Servant of God. All the material is sealed and sent to Rome.

8. The positio

It is the central document of the whole cause: a study, often hundreds or thousands of pages long, bringing together the critical biography, the testimonies and the arguments about the virtues or the martyrdom. It is prepared by the postulator, the person in charge of moving the cause forward, under the guidance of the relator.

Its full name is Positio super virtutibus (on the virtues) or super martyrio (on martyrdom). Some are so long they fill several volumes.

9. The devil’s advocate

For centuries there was an office whose nickname became proverbial: the promoter of the faith, popularly called the “devil’s advocate”. His job was to look for weak points, objections and contradictions in the cause, so that no one would be declared a saint lightly.

The 1983 reform changed the role. The promoter of the faith still exists, but now chairs the meeting of the theological consultors rather than acting as a prosecutor. The phrase, meanwhile, passed into everyday language for someone who argues the other side on purpose.

10. The consistory and being raised to the altars

When the pope approves a miracle for canonization, he calls a consistory, a meeting with the cardinals, at which the date of the ceremony is announced. The pope celebrates the canonization himself, almost always in St Peter’s Square, with a solemn Latin formula.

“Raised to the altars” is the traditional way of saying that someone has been beatified or canonized: from then on they may be venerated publicly, with their image in churches and their feast on the calendar.

The four steps

  • Servant of God: from the moment the cause opens in the diocese.
  • Venerable: when the pope approves the decree recognising heroic virtue. There is still no public cult.
  • Blessed: when a miracle through their intercession is approved. Martyrs can be beatified without a miracle, because giving one’s life for the faith is already the supreme witness. Beatification allows a cult in a diocese, region or religious order, and since 2005 it is usually celebrated by a cardinal on the pope’s behalf, in the place the new blessed came from.
  • Saint: when a second miracle, after the beatification, is approved and the pope canonizes them. Their cult extends to the whole Church.

An Argentine example: Mama Antula was declared Venerable in 2010, beatified in Santiago del Estero in 2016 and canonized by Pope Francis in Rome on 11 February 2024. She was Argentina’s first woman saint.

And the saints nobody canonized?

They are the vast majority. Canonization does not make anyone a saint: it recognises that someone already is one. That is why on 1 November the Church celebrates all the saints, including those who will never have a cause, and the Second Vatican Council reminds us that everyone is called to holiness (Lumen gentium, 40). You too.

Play today’s Mustard Seed

Seven prompts about the Bible, the saints and the Church, 30 seconds each. The rarer your correct answer, the more it’s worth.

Plant your seedHow to play →

Frequently asked questions

How long does a canonization take?
It varies enormously. Some causes take centuries; others, a few years. John Paul II was canonized nine years after his death, and Teresa of Calcutta nineteen. The documentation, the miracles and having someone to push the cause forward all play a part.
Is canonization infallible?
The common opinion of theologians is yes: when the pope canonizes, he declares definitively that the person is in heaven. Beatification, on the other hand, is not considered an infallible act.
Who pays for a canonization cause?
A cause is promoted by a “petitioner”, which may be a diocese, a religious order or an association of the faithful, and it covers the costs. In 2016 the Vatican approved rules to make the handling of those funds transparent.
What is the difference between a blessed and a saint?
A blessed has a limited cult, for example in their diocese or order. A saint may be venerated throughout the Church. Moving from one to the other generally takes a second miracle.