Skip to content
All articles

Learn

Zatti, Valdivielso, Jaime Hilario: 10 saintly brothers hardly anyone names

Asked for a saint who was a brother and not a priest, most people say St Francis of Assisi or St Martin de Porres. But there are many more: a Patagonian nurse who gave up the priesthood, the first saint born in Buenos Aires, a teacher who went deaf, and a Portuguese general who ended his days as the lowliest member of his friary.

10 min read

A Franciscan friar prays in ecstasy in the friary kitchen while angels prepare the meal, painting by Bartolomé Esteban Murillo
Image: Bartolomé Esteban Murillo, “The Angels’ Kitchen” (1646), Louvre Museum, Paris, public domain

A trick question

The fifth question of Mustard Seed #3, on the feast of St Martin de Porres, was: “Name a saint who was a religious brother, not a priest”. It sounds easy until the doubts creep in: was St Francis a priest? What about St Benedict? Or St John of God? The prompt made you think not just of saints but of the kind of life they chose.

We accepted canonized saints who took vows in an order or congregation, or lived as monks, without ever being ordained priests. Here are ten that hardly anyone named, from the rarest answer to the best known.

What is a religious brother?

A brother is a man who consecrates himself to God with vows of poverty, chastity and obedience, lives in community and is not ordained: he does not celebrate Mass or hear confessions. The Code of Canon Law explains that the consecrated life, by its nature, is “neither clerical nor lay” (can. 588 §1). You can be fully a religious without being a priest. The Catechism, for its part, teaches that the consecrated life is not part of the Church’s hierarchical structure, yet belongs undeniably to her life and holiness (CCC 914).

There are many kinds of brother. In the older orders they were the “lay brothers”, who cooked, kept the door or begged for alms; the Salesians call them “coadjutors”. Other congregations are made up only of brothers, such as the De La Salle Brothers, devoted to schools, or the Hospitaller Brothers of St John of God, devoted to the sick. Nearly every saint on this list lived that way.

1. Artémides Zatti, the nurse who gave up the priesthood

Zatti was born in Boretto, in northern Italy, on 12 October 1880, and came to Argentina with his family in 1897. At twenty he joined the Salesians to become a priest, but caught tuberculosis while nursing a sick young priest. In Viedma, Fr Evasio Garrone suggested he pray to Mary Help of Christians and promise that, if he recovered, he would give his life to the sick. He later summed it up in three words: “I believed, I promised, I was healed.” He humbly accepted giving up the priesthood, though it cost him, and in 1908 made his first profession as a coadjutor brother.

He started in the hospital pharmacy, and when Garrone died he took charge of everything: nurse, pharmacist, administrator and sometimes theatre assistant. He kept his mentor’s rule: whoever has little pays little, and whoever has nothing pays nothing. Once he asked a sister, “Have you any clothes for a twelve-year-old Jesus?”, because that is how he saw every boy who arrived. When a prisoner being treated there escaped, he was blamed and spent five days in jail, his only days off, people joked. In 1950 he fell from a ladder, diagnosed his own cancer and died on 15 March 1951. He was the first non-martyr Salesian coadjutor to be beatified (2002), and Pope Francis canonized him on 9 October 2022.

2. Héctor Valdivielso, the first saint born in Argentina

Before the Cura Brochero and before Zatti, Argentina already had a saint, though hardly anyone knows it. Héctor Valdivielso Sáez was born in Buenos Aires on 31 October 1910 to poor immigrant parents. He entered the novitiate of the Brothers of the Christian Schools in 1926 and took the name Brother Benito de Jesús.

In October 1934, during the Asturias uprising, armed men burst into the De La Salle school at Turón, a mining village. They took eight brothers and a Passionist priest who had come to hear the boys’ confessions, and on 9 October they shot them. Héctor was 24. St John Paul II canonized them on 21 November 1999.

3. Jaime Hilario Barbal, the brother who went deaf

Manuel Barbal was born in Enviny, in the Catalan Pyrenees, on 2 January 1898, and went to seminary to become a priest. He began to lose his hearing and had to leave. He knocked at the door of the De La Salle Brothers, who took him in in 1917, and he taught for sixteen years, much of it at Pibrac near Toulouse. When deafness made teaching impossible, he moved to the novitiate kitchen and garden.

In July 1936 he was arrested. He was held in Lleida and on a prison ship at Tarragona, and at his trial he would not deny being a religious, though it would have saved his life. He was shot beside the Tarragona cemetery on 18 January 1937. He was canonized on the same day as the martyrs of Turón.

4. Benildus Romançon, the teacher who was too short

Pierre Romançon was born in Thuret, in central France, on 14 June 1805. His superiors hesitated to admit him to the novitiate because he was so short. He got in anyway, in 1820, and in 1841 was sent to run a new school at Saugues, a poor village on a bare plateau.

He stayed some twenty years, teaching and running the school, doing nothing that looked extraordinary. Yet more than two hundred brothers and many priests came out of his classrooms. He died on 13 August 1862, and St Paul VI canonized him on 29 October 1967.

5. Mutien-Marie Wiaux, 58 years at the same school

Louis Wiaux was born in 1841 at Mellet, in Belgium, the son of a blacksmith. At home, evenings ended with the Rosary. He was no use at the forge, joined the De La Salle Brothers at fifteen and was sent to the boarding school at Malonne, where he stayed for fifty-eight years.

At first he struggled to teach and keep order. A brother helped him with the music and drawing classes, and in the end he taught them himself. His whole holiness was this: faithfulness in everyday things. He died at Malonne on 30 January 1917, and John Paul II canonized him on 10 December 1989.

6. Albert Chmielowski, the painter who became brother to the poor

Adam Chmielowski was born near Kraków in 1845. At seventeen he joined the Polish uprising of 1863 against Russian rule, was wounded and lost a leg. Afterwards he became a painter, and a good one. While he was painting an Ecce Homo, Christ crowned with thorns, his life began to change.

He tried the Jesuits, but it was not his place. He became a Franciscan tertiary, turned his studio into a shelter for Kraków’s homeless, and in 1888 took the name Brother Albert and founded the Albertine Brothers, followed soon after by the Sisters. He died on Christmas Day 1916. A young Karol Wojtyła wrote a play about him, Our God’s Brother, and as pope canonized him on 12 November 1989.

7. Richard Pampuri, the doctor who became a brother

Erminio Pampuri was born in Trivolzio, near Pavia, in 1897, and qualified as a doctor at the top of his class. He was a country doctor in Morimondo, where he visited the poor day and night and left them not only medicine but money, food and clothes.

In 1927 he joined the Brothers of St John of God as Brother Richard. He could have become a priest, but chose to be a hospitaller brother: he ran the dental clinic at the order’s hospital in Brescia, treating mostly working people and the poor. He died in Milan on 1 May 1930, aged 33, and John Paul II canonized him on 1 November 1989.

8. Ignatius of Laconi, the alms-collector of Cagliari

Vincenzo Cadello was born in 1701 at Laconi, in Sardinia. Seriously ill at eighteen, he promised to become a Franciscan if he recovered; he did recover, but was slow to keep his word. In 1721 he joined the Capuchins in Cagliari as a lay brother, taking the name Ignatius.

For some forty years he was the friary’s alms-collector, walking the city to beg for the friars and the poor and leaving a word of the Gospel in return. Tradition tells that a merchant who had grown rich at the expense of the poor kept insisting on giving him alms; he would not take them, and when his superior ordered him to, blood began to drip from the sack. “It is the blood of the poor,” he said. He died on 11 May 1781, and Pius XII canonized him on 21 October 1951.

9. Nuno Álvares Pereira, the general who ended up a lay brother

Nuno (1360–1431) was the great Constable of Portugal, the army commander who at the Battle of Aljubarrota, on 14 August 1385, secured the country’s independence. He married, had a daughter and was widowed young. With his fortune he built the Carmelite church and friary in Lisbon.

In 1423 he entered that same friary, and of all the options he chose the humblest: lay brother, under the name Brother Nuno of St Mary. He asked for no privileges and organised a daily distribution of food for the poor. He died on Easter Sunday, 1 April 1431, and Benedict XVI canonized him on 26 April 2009.

10. Pachomius, father of the monasteries

Pachomius was born in Egypt, to a pagan family, around 292. He was conscripted into the Roman army, and at Thebes some Christians brought food to the locked-up recruits. That kindness marked him: he was baptized in 314 and went into the desert with the hermit Palaemon.

Around 320 he founded a monastery at Tabennisi where the monks did not each live alone but in community, with shared hours, work and prayer. He wrote the first monastic rule, known to St Basil and St Benedict. According to tradition, when St Athanasius wanted to ordain him a priest, Pachomius hid to avoid it. He died in 348. He is the forefather of every brother on this list.

And the best-known

  • Francis of Assisi: the answer given most, by far. He was never a priest: according to tradition, out of humility he went no further than the diaconate. He founded a fraternity of brothers, the “Friars Minor”.
  • Martin de Porres: the second most common answer, and the saint of the day: a Dominican brother in Lima, barber and infirmarian at the friary of the Rosary.
  • John of God: also given more than once: the Portuguese man who opened a hospital in Granada and whose companions became the Hospitaller Order, an order of brothers.
  • André Bessette: a Holy Cross brother, doorkeeper of a Montreal college for decades and the driving force behind St Joseph’s Oratory.
  • Juan Macías: a Dominican brother from Extremadura, doorkeeper in Lima and friend of Martin de Porres.
  • Alphonsus Rodríguez: a Jesuit brother, doorkeeper of the college in Majorca, who encouraged St Peter Claver to go to the Americas.
  • Paschal Baylon: a Franciscan brother in love with the Eucharist, patron of Eucharistic congresses.
  • Peter of St Joseph Betancur: Guatemala’s “Hermano Pedro”, born in Tenerife, who cared for the sick and poor and founded the Bethlemite Order.

Brother Martin’s broom

Martin de Porres was called “Fray Escoba”, Brother Broom, because he never refused to sweep. Like the other saints on this list, he never presided at Mass or preached from the pulpit: he opened doors, dressed wounds, begged alms, taught classes. Jesus said that he came not to be served but to serve (Mark 10:45), and these brothers took him at his word.

Ask St Martin de Porres today for the humility to serve without seeking to be seen, and do one job at home or at work that nobody is going to thank you for.

Play today’s Mustard Seed

Seven prompts about the Bible, the saints and the Church, 30 seconds each. The rarer your correct answer, the more it’s worth.

Plant your seedHow to play →

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a religious brother and a priest?
Both may take vows of poverty, chastity and obedience, but only a priest receives the sacrament of Holy Orders: he celebrates Mass and absolves sins in Confession. A brother is a religious who is not ordained. The Code of Canon Law says that the consecrated life, by its nature, is neither clerical nor lay (can. 588 §1).
Was St Francis of Assisi a priest?
No. According to tradition, Francis was ordained a deacon but out of humility never wished to become a priest. He founded a fraternity of brothers, the Friars Minor, and many of his first companions were not priests either.
Who was the first Argentine saint?
The first saint born in Argentina is Héctor Valdivielso Sáez, a De La Salle Brother born in Buenos Aires in 1910 and martyred at Turón, Spain, in 1934. He was canonized in 1999. Later came the Cura Brochero (2016), Artémides Zatti (2022) and Mama Antula (2024).
What is a lay brother or a coadjutor brother?
They are names different orders give to religious who are not priests. “Lay brother” was used in the older orders, such as the Franciscans, Dominicans and Carmelites; “coadjutor” is the term used, for example, by the Salesians and Jesuits. Today many orders simply say “brother”.