Skip to content
All articles

Learn

The Room of Tears, infirmarii, novendiales: 10 conclave words hardly anyone knows

A pope is elected by the cardinals under 80, shut inside the Sistine Chapel, in a secret vote: he needs at least two thirds of the votes, and once someone reaches them and accepts, white smoke tells the world. The rules are set out in Universi Dominici Gregis, the apostolic constitution of St John Paul II. Behind the smoke lies a whole vocabulary that hardly anyone knows.

9 min read

Christ hands the keys to the kneeling St Peter before a wide square with an octagonal temple, fresco by Perugino in the Sistine Chapel
Image: Pietro Perugino, “Christ Handing the Keys to St Peter” (1481–82), fresco in the Sistine Chapel, Vatican City, public domain

How is a pope elected?

It was the third prompt of Mustard Seed #4, on the feast of St Charles Borromeo: “Name something connected to a conclave, the election of a pope”. The date was fitting. According to the traditional account of the life of St Pius V, in the conclave of 1565–1566 it was St Charles who, seeing that his first choice would not be elected, gathered the votes for Cardinal Ghislieri. Ghislieri resisted, and accepted on 7 January 1566 for fear of resisting the call of God.

We accepted rites, places, offices, documents and words of the conclave. We did not count the Holy Spirit as an answer, so as not to score a divine Person, although he is the real protagonist: the cardinals call on him before every step. Here is how the answers ranked, from the rarest to the most common.

1. The Room of Tears

No one named it. It is a small room right next to the Sistine Chapel, to the left of the altar, where the newly elected pope withdraws as soon as he accepts. White vestments wait for him there in three sizes, small, medium and large, because no one knows in advance who the pope will be. He takes off a cardinal’s red, puts on white and has a few minutes alone before going out to the balcony.

The name comes from what tends to happen inside: the emotion of a man who, minutes earlier, was one cardinal among many and now carries the whole Church. St John XXIII, seeing the white cassock in 1958, joked that he would be a disaster on television. Francis recalled in his autobiography, Hope, that he kept his bishop’s ring and his usual orthopaedic shoes.

2. Cum clave: with a key

“Conclave” comes from the Latin cum clave, “with a key”. The custom was born of exasperation. After the death of Clement IV in 1268, the cardinals gathered in Viterbo spent nearly three years unable to agree. The city authorities ended up shutting them in a cramped space to hurry them along, and in 1271 Gregory X was elected.

The new pope learned the lesson. In 1274, at the Second Council of Lyons, he issued the constitution Ubi periculum: the cardinals were to meet in a single room, with no partitions or hangings; if they had not chosen within three days, they would get one dish per meal for five days, and after that only bread, wine and water. His successors suspended it, until Celestine V restored it and Boniface VIII wrote it into canon law.

3. Universi Dominici Gregis, the rulebook

All the rules of the conclave are in a single document: the apostolic constitution Universi Dominici Gregis (“Of the Lord’s whole flock”), which St John Paul II signed on 22 February 1996, the feast of the Chair of St Peter. Benedict XVI amended it twice: in 2007 he restored the requirement of a two-thirds majority in every ballot, and on 22 February 2013, days before he resigned, he allowed the conclave to begin earlier if all the electors are already present.

The text foresees everything: who votes (no. 33), where the electors stay, namely the Casa Santa Marta (no. 42), how many ballots are held each day (no. 63) and what happens if no one reaches the majority (nos. 74–75). It even allows for a man who is not a bishop being elected: he must be ordained at once, and only then is the election announced to the people (nos. 88–89).

4. Scrutineers, infirmarii and revisers

Before the voting, the junior Cardinal Deacon draws nine names by lot, in public, from among all the electors (no. 64). The first three are the scrutineers, who count the votes; the next three are the infirmarii, who collect the votes of sick cardinals; the last three are the revisers, who check the whole count again.

The infirmarii take a locked box with a slot for the ballot to the sick elector and bring it back to the chapel. Before they set off, the scrutineers open it and show everyone it is empty (no. 68). At the end, the last scrutineer reads each name aloud, and if no one has reached two thirds, the constitution says it plainly: the pope has not been elected (nos. 69–70). Nobody relies on one man’s word; everything is done in threes, in full view.

5. Eligo in Summum Pontificem

The upper half of every ballot, which is rectangular, bears the printed Latin words Eligo in Summum Pontificem, “I elect as Supreme Pontiff”, and below there is room for a single name. Each cardinal writes it in secret, as far as possible in handwriting that cannot be identified as his, and folds the ballot twice. If he writes more than one name, the vote is void (no. 65).

Then he walks to the altar, beneath Michelangelo’s Last Judgement, holding up the folded ballot so it can be seen, and says aloud: “I call as my witness Christ the Lord who will be my judge, that my vote is given to the one who before God I think should be elected” (no. 66). He places the ballot on a plate and tips it into the receptacle.

6. The novendiales

When a pope dies, the first thing is not to look for a successor but to pray for him. The cardinals celebrate funeral rites for the repose of his soul for nine consecutive days (no. 27). Those nine days of Masses for the dead pope are called the novendiales.

They also set the calendar. The conclave cannot begin until fifteen full days have passed since the See fell vacant, unless all the electors are already present, and it cannot begin later than twenty (no. 37). Francis died on 21 April 2025, Easter Monday; the conclave began on 7 May.

7. The General Congregations

While the See is vacant, no one stands in for the pope: the College of Cardinals deals only with ordinary business. For that, the cardinals meet daily in the General Congregations, presided over by the Dean (nos. 7–9). Cardinals who no longer vote may attend too, and there, before the conclave, they get to know one another and talk about the state of the Church.

The Congregations settle the practical matters: the day and time of the funeral, lodging, expenses and the date when voting begins (no. 13). They also arrange for the Fisherman’s Ring and the lead seal of the dead pope to be destroyed, so that no one can use them to seal documents in his name.

8. The Mass Pro eligendo Romano Pontifice

On the morning the conclave opens, the electors celebrate in St Peter’s Basilica the votive Mass “for the election of the Roman Pontiff”, which the constitution calls Pro eligendo Papa (no. 49). It is the last time the world sees them together before the doors close.

On 7 May 2025 the homily was preached by Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re, Dean of the College of Cardinals, who was no longer a voter because he was over 80. He reminded the electors that the election of a pope is not a simple succession of persons.

9. Veni Creator Spiritus

Only one player named it. In the afternoon the cardinals walk in procession from the Pauline Chapel to the Sistine Chapel singing the Veni Creator, the ancient hymn “Come, Creator Spirit” (no. 50).

Once inside, they all swear to keep the rules and the secret (no. 53), and the Master of Papal Liturgical Celebrations calls out Extra omnes, “everyone out”: all who are not taking part in the election leave (no. 52). The cardinals are bound to secrecy, and any of the staff assisting them who break it incur automatic excommunication (nos. 55 and 58).

10. The Dean of the College of Cardinals

Again, just one player named him. The Dean presides over the General Congregations (no. 9) and, at the decisive moment, goes up to the man elected and asks him on behalf of all: “Do you accept your canonical election as Supreme Pontiff?” If he says yes, the second question follows: “By what name do you wish to be called?” (no. 87). From that instant he is Bishop of Rome and pope (no. 88).

If the Dean is already over 80, as Cardinal Re was in 2025, the questions are asked by the cardinal elector who is first in order and seniority. That time, Cardinal Pietro Parolin presided over the conclave.

And the best-known ones

  • White smoke: was by far the answer given most often. The ballots are burned with the cardinals’ notes after each count (nos. 70–71), and white smoke means there is a pope. On 8 May 2025 it rose from the chimney at 6.07 p.m., Rome time.
  • Black smoke: means no one reached two thirds. Because the ballots of two back-to-back votes are burned together (no. 70), smoke usually appears once in the morning and once in the afternoon, even though there can be up to four ballots a day.
  • Habemus Papam: is announced from the balcony of St Peter’s by the Cardinal Protodeacon, the senior Cardinal Deacon (no. 89). In 2025 it was Dominique Mamberti. Then the new pope gives his first Urbi et Orbi blessing.
  • The ballot, the two-thirds majority and the oath of secrecy: are the heart of the procedure (nos. 53, 62 and 65). In 2025, with 133 electors, 89 votes were needed.
  • Extra omnes, the Sistine Chapel, the chimney and St Peter’s Square: are what the world sees from outside.
  • The camerlengo and the sede vacante: the camerlengo looks after the goods of the Holy See while there is no pope, but he does not govern the Church.
  • The papal name, Leo XIV and Francis: we accepted these too. Francis was elected in 2013; Leo XIV, the American Robert Prevost, on 8 May 2025, on the fourth ballot, the second day of the conclave.

I call as my witness Christ

What people remember about a conclave is the smoke and the balcony, but the most solemn moment is another: in the Sistine Chapel, after calling on the Holy Spirit, each cardinal swears before Christ, who will be his judge, that he is voting for the one he believes before God should be elected. In May 2025 that oath, repeated ballot after ballot, ended in white smoke and the name of Leo XIV, who came out on the balcony with the greeting “Peace be with you all”.

Say an Our Father today for Pope Leo XIV, that the Lord may sustain him in the task he accepted that afternoon.

Play today’s Mustard Seed

Seven prompts about the Bible, the saints and the Church, 30 seconds each. The rarer your correct answer, the more it’s worth.

Plant your seedHow to play →

Frequently asked questions

How many cardinals vote in a conclave?
The cardinals who had not turned 80 before the day the See fell vacant. The constitution sets a maximum of 120 electors (Universi Dominici Gregis, 33), although in May 2025, because of the number of cardinals under 80 at the time, 133 entered the Sistine Chapel.
How many votes does a pope need?
At least two thirds of the electors present (Universi Dominici Gregis, 62). Since Benedict XVI’s reform of 2007 that majority is always required: if the voting drags on, only the two leading names can be voted for, and they themselves do not vote in that round (no. 75).
How long does a conclave last?
There is no fixed limit. There is a single ballot on the first afternoon, then up to four a day (no. 63), with pauses for prayer if three days pass without a result (no. 74). Recent conclaves have been short: Francis and Leo XIV were both elected on the second day.
Why is the smoke white or black?
Because after each count the ballots and the cardinals’ notes are burned (nos. 70–71). The constitution says nothing about the colour of the smoke: it is a custom. So that there is no doubt in the square, chemicals are now added to colour it white or black.