Learn
The face cloth, Joanna and the gardener: 10 details of Easter morning hardly anyone remembers
All four Gospels tell the story of Easter morning, and each one notices different things. Everyone remembers the stone rolled away and the empty tomb. Few remember a cloth rolled up in a corner, a woman from Herod’s court or the two words the messenger added at the end: “and Peter”.
10 min read

Four accounts of one morning
The story is told in Matthew 28:1–10, Mark 16:1–8, Luke 24:1–12 and John 20:1–18. All four agree on the essentials: it is the first day of the week, very early; some women go to the tomb and find it empty; someone tells them that Jesus has been raised. In the details, each evangelist tells what his community remembered: who went, how many angels they saw, what was said. Those differences are the kind real witnesses leave, not the kind a story made up at a desk would have.
It was the fourth prompt of Mustard Seed #2, on 2 November, All Souls’ Day: the day we pray for our dead, we do it looking towards this morning. These are the details that scored highest in the game, from the rarest answer to the most common. Quotations follow the New American Bible.
1. The face cloth rolled up by itself
This was the rarest answer of the day. When Peter goes into the tomb he sees the burial cloths lying there, “and the cloth that had covered his head, not with the burial cloths but rolled up in a separate place” (John 20:7). It is a tiny detail, and John records it carefully. A thief in a hurry does not carry off a naked body and leave the cloths folded: the order inside the tomb points to something that was not a robbery.
The Church sings about it every Easter Sunday in the sequence Victimae paschali laudes, where Mary Magdalene is asked what she saw on the way, and she answers by naming the angelic witnesses, “sudarium et vestes”: the face cloth and the grave clothes. Oviedo Cathedral in Spain venerates a cloth that tradition identifies with this one; the Church has not ruled on its authenticity, and faith does not depend on it.
2. Joanna, the woman from Herod’s court
Only Luke names her among the women who went to the tomb: “Mary Magdalene, Joanna, and Mary the mother of James” (Luke 24:10). He had introduced her earlier, when he tells us that some women followed Jesus through Galilee: Joanna, the wife of Chuza, Herod’s steward, along with Susanna and many others who provided for Jesus and the Twelve out of their own resources (Luke 8:3).
In other words, the wife of the household manager of the same Herod Antipas who had John the Baptist beheaded was putting her money at the service of Jesus. A woman with standing at court who followed the Teacher to the cross and to the tomb. Luke names her twice and says nothing more about her; it is enough to know she was there.
3. “Woman, why are you weeping?”
Mary Magdalene stays outside the tomb, weeping, after Peter and the other disciple have gone home. She bends down and sees two angels in white sitting where the body had been. They ask her: “Woman, why are you weeping?” (John 20:13). She answers that they have taken her Lord and she does not know where they have laid him.
A moment later Jesus asks her the same question and adds another: “Woman, why are you weeping? Whom are you looking for?” (John 20:15). These are almost the first words of the risen Lord in John’s Gospel, and they are not a speech: they are a question about her grief. On All Souls’ Day, when many people stand at a grave, that question sounds different.
4. “Rabbouni” and “Stop holding on to me”
Mary does not recognise him until Jesus calls her by name: “Mary!” She turns and says to him in Hebrew, “Rabbouni,” which means Teacher (John 20:16). No explanation or miracle was needed: it was enough for him to say her name in the voice she knew. It is what Jesus had said of the good shepherd, who calls his sheep by name, and they recognise his voice (John 10:3–4).
Then comes one of the most painted lines in the history of art, known by its Latin form, Noli me tangere: “Stop holding on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father” (John 20:17). It is not a rejection. Jesus has not come back to his old life, as Lazarus did; now he must be found in a new way. And he sends her: go to my brothers. That is why tradition calls her the “apostle to the apostles”, and in 2016 Pope Francis raised her memorial on 22 July to the rank of a feast.
5. The women who took hold of his feet
Matthew tells another scene. The women run to tell the disciples, fearful yet overjoyed, and Jesus meets them on the way and greets them. They approach, “embraced his feet, and did him homage” (Matthew 28:9).
The gesture says two things at once. To hold his feet is to touch a real body: this is no ghost or vision. To fall down in homage is to worship: this body is God’s. Then Jesus repeats what the angel said, “Do not be afraid”, and gives them a message for his “brothers”, the same word he uses in John. Those who had abandoned him are still his brothers.
6. The other disciple “saw and believed”
Alerted by Mary Magdalene, Peter and “the other disciple whom Jesus loved” run to the tomb. The other one runs faster and arrives first, but he does not go in: he waits for Peter (John 20:2–6). This is the scene in Burnand’s painting at the top of this article, with the two faces tense with hope and fear.
Peter goes in and looks. “Then the other disciple also went in, the one who had arrived at the tomb first, and he saw and believed” (John 20:8). He is the first person in the Gospel to believe in the Resurrection, and he believes before seeing the risen Lord, from the cloths alone. The Catechism notes that the empty tomb is not in itself a direct proof, but it was an essential sign for everyone, and that this disciple, seeing the state of the linens, “saw and believed” (Catechism, 640).
7. The gardener
When Jesus speaks to her, Mary Magdalene does not recognise him. “She thought it was the gardener” (John 20:15), and she says: if you carried him away, tell me where you laid him and I will take him. It is not an absurd mistake. John had told us that where Jesus was crucified there was a garden, with a new tomb, and that is where they buried him (John 19:41–42).
Christian readers since ancient times have heard an echo of Genesis here: human history began in a garden, and the new creation begins in another. Fra Angelico painted the scene in the friary of San Marco in Florence with Jesus carrying a hoe over his shoulder, like a real gardener. Mary’s mistake turned out to be an insight.
8. The young man dressed in white
In Mark, the women set out worried about a practical problem: “Who will roll back the stone for us from the entrance to the tomb?” (Mark 16:3). When they arrive, it has already been rolled back. They go in, and “they saw a young man sitting on the right side, clothed in a white robe” (Mark 16:5). Mark does not call him an angel, though the white robe shows he comes from God. Matthew speaks of an angel, Luke of two men in dazzling garments and John of two angels.
His first words are those of every messenger from God: “Do not be amazed! You seek Jesus of Nazareth, the crucified” (Mark 16:6). He calls him “the crucified” even after the Resurrection: the wounds do not disappear, they become glorious. Mark ends the scene with the women fleeing the tomb, trembling and bewildered (Mark 16:8).
9. “And Peter”
The young man’s message has a detail found only in Mark: “go and tell his disciples and Peter” that Jesus is going before them to Galilee (Mark 16:7). Peter was one of the disciples; there was no need to name him separately. But a few days earlier he had denied Jesus three times, and when the cock crowed he broke down and wept (Mark 14:66–72).
Those two words are forgiveness offered in advance: the one who denied him was not left out. According to an ancient tradition, Mark’s Gospel records Peter’s preaching in Rome; if so, Peter himself would have wanted that detail told. Paul confirms that the risen Lord appeared first to Cephas, that is, to Peter (1 Corinthians 15:5).
10. The earthquake and the guards
Only Matthew tells it: “And behold, there was a great earthquake”, an angel came down from heaven, rolled back the stone and sat on it (Matthew 28:2). The earth had already shaken on Friday, at the moment Jesus died (Matthew 27:51). Now it shakes again, and the angel sits on the stone as if on a defeated enemy.
The guards were there because the chief priests had asked Pilate to seal the tomb and watch it, so that no one could steal the body (Matthew 27:62–66). That morning “the guards were shaken with fear of him and became like dead men” (Matthew 28:4): those guarding a dead man look dead, and the dead man is alive. Afterwards they were paid to say, “His disciples came by night and stole him while we were asleep” (Matthew 28:11–15).
And the best-known answers
- The angel: was the answer given most often in the game. In Matthew he tells the women not to be afraid and announces: “He is not here, for he has been raised just as he said” (Matthew 28:5–6).
- The stone rolled away and the empty tomb: are in all four Gospels. The Catechism calls the empty tomb “an essential sign” of the Resurrection (Catechism, 640).
- Mary Magdalene: is the only woman named in all four accounts. With the other women, she was among the first messengers of the Resurrection to the apostles themselves (Catechism, 641).
- Peter: runs to the tomb and, according to Luke, “saw the burial cloths alone” and went home amazed at what had happened (Luke 24:12).
- “He is not here, but he has been raised” is the heart of the message, with the question Luke gives the two men: “Why do you seek the living one among the dead?” (Luke 24:5–6).
- The spices and the first day of the week: “Mary Magdalene, Mary, the mother of James, and Salome bought spices so that they might go and anoint him” (Mark 16:1). It was the first day of the week, the day Christians began to call “the Lord’s day”, Sunday.
A morning for those who weep
Easter morning begins with women going to tend a dead body, with spices and with tears. They expected nothing more. They found an empty tomb and a name spoken aloud. The Catechism reminds us that Jesus’ Resurrection was not a return to earthly life, like that of Lazarus, but a passage to another life that can no longer die (Catechism, 646).
If you are missing someone who has died, put yourself where Mary Magdalene stood by the tomb and hear the question Jesus asked her: why are you weeping? Tell him whom you are looking for, and pray for that person: “Eternal rest grant unto them, O Lord.”
Play today’s Mustard Seed
Seven prompts about the Bible, the saints and the Church, 30 seconds each. The rarer your correct answer, the more it’s worth.
Plant your seedHow to play →Frequently asked questions
- Who reached the empty tomb first?
- The women. In all four Gospels they are the first to find the tomb empty, with Mary Magdalene always among them. Then, alerted by them, Peter and the beloved disciple run to the tomb. The disciple arrives first but waits for Peter to go in (John 20:1–8).
- How many angels were at the tomb?
- It depends on the Gospel. Matthew speaks of one angel sitting on the stone, Mark of a young man dressed in white, Luke of two men in dazzling garments and John of two angels sitting where the body had been. Each evangelist tells what his community remembered; all agree on the message: Jesus has been raised.
- What is the face cloth of Jesus?
- It is the cloth that had covered Jesus’ head. John says it was rolled up in a separate place, apart from the burial cloths (John 20:7). It should not be confused with the Shroud of Turin, which tradition identifies with the sheet that wrapped the body. The Church allows both relics to be venerated without ruling on their authenticity.
- What does “Stop holding on to me” mean?
- It is what Jesus says to Mary Magdalene in John 20:17, known in Latin as Noli me tangere. It is not a rejection: Jesus has not returned to his former life but is going to the Father, and Mary must learn to find him in a new way. That is why he immediately sends her to announce the Resurrection to the disciples.