Skip to content
All meditations

Second Week

Three Classes of People

The Three Classes of People is a parable by St Ignatius about three ways of reacting to an attachment that keeps us from God. The first puts it off until later, the second wants God to fit in with what he has already decided, and the third places himself in God’s hands, ready to keep or let go of what he has, as God wills. The meditation helps us find out which of the three we really are.

The text of St Ignatius

Preparatory prayer

Ask God our Lord for the grace that all my intentions, actions and works may be directed purely to the service and praise of his Divine Majesty.

Composition of place

Place myself before God our Lord and all his saints, desiring to know what is most pleasing to his Divine Majesty.

Petition

Ask for the grace to choose what is more for the glory of his Divine Majesty and the salvation of my soul.

Points

  1. The first kind of person would like to be free of attachment to what they have, so as to find God in peace, but does nothing about it until the hour of death.
  2. The second kind wants to be free of the attachment but to keep the thing, so that God comes round to what they want, rather than they going to what God wants.
  3. The third kind wants to be free of the attachment in such a way that they have no leaning toward keeping the thing or giving it up, but want to want it or not only as God moves their will. They become indifferent.

Colloquy

Make the same three colloquies as in the Two Standards (to Mary, to the Son and to the Father), asking for the grace to be like the third kind of person.

What it is and where it sits in the Exercises

It is found at numbers 149 to 157, on the same fourth day of the Second Week as the Two Standards (no. 149). Ignatius calls them “binarios”, a word of his time meaning a pair or, simply, a type of person. He presents three cases and asks the retreatant to look at themselves in them honestly.

The story (no. 150) is concrete: three people have each acquired ten thousand ducats, a fortune, and did not do so purely or as they ought for the love of God. All three want to be saved and to find God in peace, ridding themselves of the burden and obstacle that this attachment is. The composition of place (no. 151) is to stand before God and all his saints, so as to desire and know what pleases him most. The petition (no. 152) is to ask for the grace to choose what is more for the glory of God and the salvation of one’s soul.

The Two Standards showed the deception from the outside; the Three Classes show it from within, on the ground of our own will.

Three ways of responding

The first (no. 153) would like to be rid of the attachment so as to find God in peace, but does not use the means until the hour of death. This is the person who says “one day”: they know what has to change but always leave it for later.

The second (no. 154) also wants to be rid of the attachment, but while keeping the thing, “so that God comes to where he wants”. This is the subtlest, because he does good things, prays and gives alms, but has already decided the outcome and only wants God to sign it off. He bargains with God instead of listening to him.

The third (no. 155) wants to be rid of the attachment in such a way that he has no leaning towards keeping the thing or not keeping it, but wants only to want it or not want it as God puts it into his will. Meanwhile he acts as if he had already let it go in his heart, and puts all his effort into wanting nothing unless the service of God moves him to it. This is the indifference Ignatius asked for in the Principle and Foundation (no. 23): not coldness, but inner freedom.

A very practical note

Ignatius knows that we often fall short of the third way. So he adds a note (no. 157): when we feel an attachment to, or a repugnance against, actual poverty, when we are not indifferent, it helps a great deal, in order to extinguish that disordered affection, to ask in the colloquies, even though the flesh resists, that the Lord should choose us for actual poverty, and to say that we want it, ask for it and beg for it, provided it is for the service and praise of his divine goodness.

It is a realistic way of teaching: when the heart leans too far one way, we honestly ask for the opposite, to bring it back into balance. The point is not to force a decision, but not to let the attachment decide for us.

The Catechism puts it in other words: Jesus asks his disciples to prefer him to everything and everyone (no. 2544), and abandonment to the providence of the Father frees us from anxiety about tomorrow (no. 2547). The colloquies are those of the Two Standards, to Our Lady, to the Son and to the Father (no. 156).

Pray it with the Bible

  • Mark 10:17-22: The rich young man keeps the commandments, but when Jesus invites him to leave everything and follow him, he goes away sad, because he had many possessions.
  • Luke 12:16-21: The rich man who plans bigger barns and gives no thought to God: “Fool! This night your soul is required of you.”
  • Luke 9:57-62: Those who want to follow Jesus but first want to do other things: a portrait of the one who always leaves it for later.
  • Matthew 13:44-46: The hidden treasure and the fine pearl: whoever finds them sells everything with joy. Freedom comes from having found something better.
  • Luke 19:1-10: Zacchaeus welcomes Jesus into his house and, without anyone demanding it, decides to give half his goods to the poor.

How to pray it, step by step

  1. 1.Get ready and say the preparatory prayer

    Find a quiet place and a set time, 20 to 30 minutes. Ask that all your intentions, actions and works be directed purely to the service and praise of God.

  2. 2.Stand before God

    Imagine yourself in the presence of God and all the saints, who want what is good for you. You are not before a judge, but before those who want you free.

  3. 3.Make the petition

    Ask for the grace to choose what is more for the glory of God and the good of your soul.

  4. 4.Name your attachment

    Think of something concrete you find hard to let go of: a plan, a possession, a relationship, a habit, an image of yourself. Place it simply before God.

  5. 5.See yourself in the three classes

    Ask honestly: am I putting it off, like the first? Am I asking God to approve what I have already decided, like the second? Or am I ready to keep it or leave it as he wills?

  6. 6.Ask for the opposite if you need to

    If you notice your heart leaning hard one way, do as Ignatius teaches and humbly ask for the opposite grace. End with the three colloquies: to Our Lady, to the Son and to the Father.

Questions for your prayer

  • What are my “ten thousand ducats” today: what do I have, or seek, that I did not acquire purely out of love for God?
  • Which decision have I been putting off for a long time?
  • In what matter am I asking God to come round to what I want?
  • What frightens me about truly putting myself in his hands?
  • What would help me trust the Father’s providence more?

Frequently asked questions

What does “binario” mean in the Exercises?

It is an expression of the time meaning a pair or a type of person. St Ignatius presents three types of people facing the same attachment (nos. 149-157).

What is the difference between the second and the third class?

The second wants to be rid of the attachment while keeping the thing, and expects God to fit in with his decision. The third does not decide in advance: he is ready to keep or to leave it according to what God shows him.

Is Ignatian indifference feeling nothing?

No. It is inner freedom to choose what pleases God most. You can feel strong inclinations; indifference means they do not make the decision for you.

What if I can’t manage to be like the third class?

Ignatius suggests asking in prayer, even when it is hard, for the opposite of what you are attached to, provided it is for God’s service (no. 157). It is a path, not an exam.

Updated 31 October 2026

Adapted from the Spiritual Exercises of St Ignatius of Loyola (1548).