Skip to content
All meditations

Rules for a true sense of the Church

Thinking with the Church

The Rules for thinking with the Church close the book of the Exercises. St Ignatius wrote them at a time of deep division among Christians, so that someone leaving the retreat with a renewed love of Christ would not live it on their own, but within his Church, with humility and without a spirit of bitter criticism.

The text of St Ignatius

To be right in everything, we should always be ready to believe that what seems white to me is black, if the hierarchical Church so defines it.

  1. 1.Obedience and praise

    Setting aside all judgement of our own, we should keep our minds ready and prompt to obey in everything the true Spouse of Christ our Lord, our holy Mother the hierarchical Church.

  2. 2.Sacraments and liturgy

    Praise confession to a priest and receiving the Most Holy Sacrament. Praise hearing Mass often, as well as hymns, psalms and prayers.

  3. 3.Religious life

    Praise highly religious orders, virginity and continence, and marriage less than any of these.

  4. 4.About those in authority

    We should be quicker to praise their rules and recommendations than to criticise them, because speaking ill of them in their absence, before simple people, causes more scandal than good.

  5. 5.Avoid comparisons

    We should not compare people living now with the blessed of the past (saying “he knows more than St Augustine” or “she is another St Francis”), because it is a great injury to the saints.

What they are and where they sit in the Exercises

They are found at nos. 352-370, the last pages of the book. Their full title reads: “For the true attitude of mind which we ought to have in the Church militant, let the following rules be observed” (no. 352). There are eighteen rules, and the phrase “thinking with the Church” (in Latin, sentire cum Ecclesia) became one of the hallmarks of Ignatian spirituality.

Many scholars think Ignatius drafted much of them during his studies in Paris, between 1528 and 1535, when the controversies of the Reformation were dividing Europe and many people were mocking the Church’s practices. The rules respond to that situation: not with polemic, but with a basic attitude of heart.

Praise before criticism

The first rule sets the tone: laying aside all judgement of our own, keep the mind ready and prompt to obey in everything the true Spouse of Christ our Lord, our holy Mother the hierarchical Church (no. 353). The image of the bride is no accident: the Church is not an administration but Christ’s beloved bride, as the Catechism also teaches (no. 796).

Then come many rules that begin with the same verb: to praise. Praise confession to a priest and frequent Communion (no. 354); hearing Mass often, hymns, psalms and the Divine Office (no. 355); religious orders, virginity and continence (no. 356); vows (no. 357); relics, pilgrimages, indulgences and candles lit in churches (no. 358); fasts and abstinence (no. 359); church buildings and images (no. 360); and all the precepts of the Church (no. 361).

It is a list of exactly what was being ridiculed at the time. Ignatius does not ask us to pretend all is well, but to look first for the good in each practice before looking for the fault.

How to speak about faults

The rule about superiors is very timely. It asks us to be quicker to approve and praise their decisions and customs than to find fault with them. And it explains why: speaking ill of them in public, before ordinary people, causes more grumbling and scandal than good. But it adds something important: faults should be raised with the people who can put them right (no. 362).

This is not a call to keep quiet about everything, but to speak well: to the right person, seeking a remedy rather than letting off steam. The next rule asks us to value both the Fathers of the Church, such as St Jerome, St Augustine and St Gregory, and the scholastic theologians, such as St Thomas and St Bonaventure (no. 363), and the one after warns against comparisons like “he knows more than St Augustine” or “she is another St Francis” (no. 364).

“What seems white to me”

The most quoted rule, and the most misunderstood, is the thirteenth: to be right in everything, hold that what seems white to me is black if the hierarchical Church so defines it (no. 365). Read on its own, it seems to ask us to stop thinking. But Ignatius gives the reason straight away: between Christ the Bridegroom and the Church his Bride it is the same Spirit who governs and guides us for the salvation of our souls.

He is speaking of faith and of what the Church teaches with authority, not of colours or questions of fact. It is the humility of someone who knows their personal view can be mistaken and trusts that the Spirit guides the Church. The Catechism gives the balance: the Magisterium is not above the Word of God but is its servant, teaching only what has been handed on to it (no. 86); and the faithful, mindful of Christ’s words “whoever listens to you listens to me”, receive with docility the teaching their pastors give them (no. 87).

Speaking carefully about grace

The last rules touch on the great debates of the sixteenth century: predestination, faith, works and grace. Ignatius asks that these be spoken of prudently, so as not to suggest that nothing depends on us or that works do not matter, and so as not to take away anyone’s freedom or effort (nos. 366-369).

The final rule ends on a note of love: above all we should value serving God out of pure love, but we should also praise the fear of God, because filial fear is devout and holy, and even servile fear helps a person rise out of mortal sin (no. 370).

Pray it with the Bible

  • Ephesians 5:25-27: Christ loved the Church and handed himself over for her. The Church is his bride, not a foreign institution.
  • Luke 10:16: “Whoever listens to you listens to me.”
  • John 17:20-21: Jesus prays for the unity of those who will believe in him: that they may all be one.
  • 1 Timothy 3:15: The Church of the living God is the pillar and foundation of truth.
  • Matthew 18:15: If your brother sins, go and tell him his fault between you and him alone: correction is made to the person who can remedy it, not behind their back.

How to pray it, step by step

  1. 1.Start with thanks

    List what you have received from the Church: baptism, the Eucharist, forgiveness, particular people who brought you closer to God.

  2. 2.Choose one rule

    Don’t try to pray all eighteen at once. Pick one, such as praising frequent Mass or raising faults with those who can remedy them.

  3. 3.Look for the good first

    Think of a practice of the Church you find hard or criticise. Ask what good it seeks and whom it has helped.

  4. 4.Check how you speak

    Remember the last time you criticised a priest, a bishop or your parish. Did you speak to someone who could fix it, or just pass it on?

  5. 5.Read what the Church teaches

    When you have a question of faith, look up what the Catechism says before settling on an opinion.

  6. 6.Ask for the grace

    Ask the Lord to love the Church as he loves her, with her saints and her sinners, starting with yourself.

  7. 7.End with a concrete step

    Go to a weekday Mass, pray for your bishop or help out in your parish. Love is shown more in deeds than in words.

Questions for your prayer

  • What do I feel when I hear the word “Church”: gratitude, distance, anger, belonging?
  • Which practices of the Church do I find it hard to see the good in?
  • When I see a fault, do I speak to someone who can remedy it, or to people who can’t?
  • Which teaching of the Church do I find hard to accept, and what would help me understand it better?
  • How can I serve the Church this week with a concrete gesture?

Frequently asked questions

What does “thinking with the Church” mean?

Thinking, loving and acting in harmony with the Church, not out of outward obedience but because we believe the same Spirit guides Christ and his bride, the Church (no. 365).

Does the “what seems white to me” rule ask us to stop thinking?

No. It concerns the faith the Church teaches with authority, not questions of fact. It asks for the humility not to set our own judgement above the faith of the Church, and the Catechism recalls that the Magisterium is the servant of the Word of God (no. 86).

Do these rules forbid criticising pastors?

No. They ask us not to speak ill of them in public to the scandal of ordinary people, and instead to take faults to those who can put them right (no. 362).

How many rules are there?

Eighteen, at nos. 353-370 of the Exercises, introduced by the title at no. 352. This page summarises five of them.

Updated 3 November 2026

Adapted from the Spiritual Exercises of St Ignatius of Loyola (1548).